Cafe and Bagels on Anna Maria Island
Breakfast and Lunch Served Daily
Bagels & Bakery
Breakfast Sandwiches
Salads
Breafast Items
Sandwhiches
Coffee
What People Are Saying
Sydney Pavina
June, 2024
By far one of the best spots to grab a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich on the island! Every time we eat here, we leave happy. The portion sizes are great and everything tastes fresh.
Leigh Ann Virzi
April 2024
Wow! Our first time here! Owner is fabulous and extremely helpful and has a wonderful sense of humor! Cute and quaint! If you have not tried it… you really need to! Excellent value!! Even added some fresh fruit!!
Lisa Adinolfi
August, 2023
This is the best bagel in Florida ! Coming from Brooklyn NY I can say that I haven’t had a better bagel in years .!!! The food is so fresh and the tomatoes are garden grown . They put extra love into the food they serve.
Robert Bleckinger
July, 2023
We love this place. People are great, food is good. They’re so nice to our dog. Walked past there tonight (photo) and the dog was perplexed why a bagel place would be closed at 9pm. Promised her we’ll go in the morning.
Julia Kozodoy
July, 2023
Such a great bagel! Owner was very nice and let us know what was most popular. We got the everything bagel with the delicious fresh ham, eggs, and cheese. Very good and love the laid back vibes.
Celebrating 30 Years and Earning the People’s Choice Award 27 times
Welcome to Paradise Cafe!
Located in the heart of Anna Maria Island, we offer fresh New York-style bagels, hearty breakfasts, and delicious lunches. Our menu features quality ingredients, including local eggs and fresh tomatoes. Expect generous portions that satisfy every appetite.
At Paradise Cafe, we support our community by showcasing local artists and businesses. Our cozy, welcoming environment is perfect for enjoying a meal with friends and family. Celebrating 30 years of great food and service, we invite you to come and taste the love in every bite